The night Sitraka stopped breathing, her hospital had one ventilator, and it was already in use by another patient. She suffered a first cardiac arrest, from which she was revived, then a second one that proved fatal. Her fiancé, Guillaume Pariset, has not forgotten a single detail of those hours. On Wednesday, 18 November, he sat in a courtroom in Madagascar as the trial over the Ambohimalaza tragedy finally opened, seventeen months after more than thirty people, most of them young, died after eating together at a birthday party near Antananarivo in June 2025.
For the families filling the courtroom, the first day of proceedings brought a moment they had long waited for, and a surprise. A doctor called by the victims’ relatives, Professor Pierre Rasolonirina, was given access to the analyses carried out after the deaths. His testimony contradicted every explanation offered since the tragedy. According to him, the analyses reveal neither toxic plants nor botulism, the two theories that had circulated for months, but the presence of methanol, a highly toxic alcohol. He also identified sleeping pills, and, in the stomach of one victim, GHB, a powerful sedative.
The findings land heavily on families who say they have spent more than a year in uncertainty. For them, the fog surrounding the case amounts to a second ordeal, layered on top of the loss itself. Nearly 40,000 people followed the hearing live on the internet, a measure of how deeply the drama shook the country and unsettled those in power.
Meanwhile, the testimony adds a third explanation to a case already marked by competing accounts. In June 2025, several Malagasy medical sources, cross-checked at the time by RFI, pointed to a single serious lead: botulism, a severe intoxication caused by a toxin that develops in poorly preserved food. Blurred vision, difficulty swallowing, respiratory distress. The symptoms, they said, were typical. The government of the day never embraced that theory. In July 2025, President Andry Rajoelina announced on television that the deaths were the result of a deliberate poisoning with plants, motivated by a family vendetta. Only after his fall from power in October was the botulism lead raised. The authorities’ silence, and analyses conducted abroad that were kept confidential, fed suspicion, and some families accused officials of smothering the affair.
Guillaume Pariset’s own account traces the human cost of those confused hours. The day after the party, the symptoms appeared: migraine, dizziness, blurred vision, a dry throat. Sitraka’s condition deteriorated quickly, and by the evening she could no longer breathe. What he remembers is the absence of the equipment that might have saved her. “There were no ventilators available. There was only one for the whole hospital, and it was already allocated to another patient,” he says. “She had a first cardiac arrest, which they were able to reverse. She had a second cardiac arrest, and that one was fatal.”
Sitraka died on 15 June 2025, after attending the birthday celebration. Her fiancé insists that what he seeks is not retribution. “We are not asking for vengeance. We are not asking for an artificial culprit on whom to pour our hatred. We simply want the truth, because only then can we mourn,” he says.
Eleven people are on trial, among them the organiser of the party and her mother, who have been detained for more than a year. Yet no one has so far explained how the substances identified by Professor Rasolonirina ended up at the celebration. His testimony adds a new uncertainty to an already murky file, without shedding light on the circumstances of the tragedy itself.
The trial continues on Thursday, 19 November, with the families of the victims watching closely, still searching for the truth they say they need before they can begin to grieve.