For the people arrested for carrying straps to secure their placards, the state of protest law in England and Wales is not an abstract debate. It is the difference between making their voices heard and facing police intervention for doing nothing more than holding a sign. That uncertainty is why the fate of a government report, now sitting unpublished for more than five months, matters far beyond Whitehall.
A year has passed since the Government launched an independent review of protest laws, and the public is still waiting to see what it found. In October 2025, following the terrorist attack on a Manchester synagogue, the Home Secretary asked Lord Macdonald, the former Director of Public Prosecutions, to examine whether public order and hate crime laws are fit for purpose, and whether they strike the right balance between free speech, the right to protest and keeping communities safe. Lord Macdonald handed his report to the Home Secretary at the end of May. Since then, ministers have told Parliament it will be published “shortly”, but no date has been set.
The delay has not stopped new restrictions from arriving. The Crime and Policing Act 2026 gave police fresh powers to limit repeat protests and to ban face coverings in designated areas. Those powers came into force on 29 June, after Lord Macdonald had submitted his report but before Parliament or the public could read it. The Equality and Human Rights Commission had recommended waiting for the review to conclude. The Government pressed ahead regardless.
For anyone who wants to protest lawfully, the rules have become harder to navigate with each passing year. Five years of successive legislation have expanded police powers, created new criminal offences and lowered the threshold for police intervention. The Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Act 2022 made it easier for officers to impose conditions on demonstrations, dictating where people can go, how long they can stay and even how loud they can be. The Public Order Act 2023 went further, allowing police to stop and search protesters without suspicion and making it a crime to be “equipped for locking on”, a provision under which people have been arrested simply for carrying straps to secure their placards. Between June 2022 and March 2025, police imposed conditions on 640 protests.
What was once a relatively self-contained set of rules in the Public Order Act 1986 is now layered with wave after wave of new law. The result, as the review’s own terms of reference acknowledge, is a legal framework that is “complex and perceived to be applied inconsistently”. Officers struggle to police it consistently, and ordinary people are left unsure how to exercise their rights without falling foul of it.
Liberty, which was among the many organisations that fed evidence into the review, argues that the report is precisely the chance to take stock that the Government itself has said is needed. Ministers have acknowledged that “a wider conversation is needed” about police powers and the right to protest. A review commissioned by the Government and drawing on evidence from a wide range of organisations, Liberty argues, should be open to public and parliamentary scrutiny.
In its own evidence, Liberty called for a wholesale simplification of public order law. That would include repealing the most restrictive measures introduced since 2022, among them suspicion-less stop and searches and Serious Disruption Prevention Orders, which can ban individuals from protesting altogether. It would also mean reaffirming a genuinely high threshold for “serious disruption”, a threshold ministers tried to lower in 2023 until Liberty challenged the move in court and won.
The stakes are about more than legal tidiness. Protest is protected, Liberty argues, precisely because it allows people to challenge those in power, even when doing so causes inconvenience or disruption. But a right that has become increasingly risky to exercise is not one people can rely on. A law so tangled and unclear can deter people from making their voices heard at all. Protest, the organisation says, should be treated as a fundamental right to be facilitated, not a threat to be mitigated and controlled.
The call now is straightforward: publish the Macdonald Review in full, and without further delay, so that Parliament and the public can see the evidence and the wider conversation the Government itself has called for can finally begin. Whether ministers finally set a date remains the open question.