Refuge: justice system still failing many survivors

Refuge: justice system still failing many survivors

Charity says lengthy trials and low conviction rates show delivery gaps

Refuge’s statement on the Russell Brand guilty verdicts opens with a blunt assessment of how the systems meant to protect women are actually performing. The charity called the convictions long overdue justice for survivors whose lives have been devastated, and an important signal that survivors’ voices matter and abusers will be held accountable. Yet it also stressed that not all survivors in the trial received a guilty verdict, and that every survivor deserves to be believed regardless of whether the charges in their case result in a conviction.

Published on Refuge’s website, the statement places significant weight on the operational realities of seeking justice: the length of the process, the experience of going through a trial, and the services survivors rely on afterwards. While the convictions are welcome for some of the brave survivors involved, Refuge argues that the lengthy justice process, a re-traumatising trial experience and mixed verdicts reflect the unacceptable barriers faced by survivors across the board.

Those barriers, in Refuge’s account, run through every stage of delivery. Reporting takes an enormous amount of strength. Survivors are all too often met with victim-blaming, dismissal and damaging accusations of false claims, compounding the harms they have already experienced. Many women do not report abuse at all because of an understandable lack of confidence in the justice system, leaving the services built to support them dealing with the consequences of that gap.

The data points to the scale of the challenge. Recent ONS figures show that around one in ten adults, 9.6 percent, experienced domestic abuse in the last year alone, and Refuge says this figure represents just the tip of the iceberg. Conviction rates for violence against women and girls offences remain alarmingly low despite the grave scale of the issue, a gap the charity frames as a failure of the machinery meant to deliver justice.

Meanwhile, Refuge is particularly critical of practice inside the system itself. It says it is deeply troubling that professionals in the justice system continue to perpetuate harmful myths about abuse, including the idea that a delay in reporting, or the fact that a survivor did not physically resist an assault, should undermine their testimony. In the charity’s view, these are dangerous myths rooted in a misrepresentation of the real dynamics of abuse and the complex reasons why survivors may delay coming forward or not fight back. It argues they cannot be legitimised under the guise of legal argument, and warns that the consequences for survivors are devastating and the stakes could not be higher.

Against that backdrop, the verdicts are read as accountability for a serial perpetrator whose actions were sickeningly shielded by some of the individuals around him. But Refuge returns to the wider delivery question: countless survivors are unable to secure convictions and continue to be failed by the systems meant to protect them. Its response is a concrete set of demands. The charity continues to call for mandatory training for professionals in the criminal justice system, proper resourcing for police, and sustainable funding for the specialist services that support survivors. It also wants higher conviction rates for violence against women and girls, alongside robust preventative measures so that perpetrators, including those in the public eye, cannot continue abusing women with impunity. That, Refuge says, means challenging the wider culture of misogyny that enables abuse, protects perpetrators and puts women and girls in danger.

For survivors needing help now, Refuge points to the National Domestic Abuse Helpline, available 24 hours a day, 365 days a year, and says it will keep advocating until abuse is no longer tolerated. The full statement can be read at https://refuge.org.uk/news/refuge-responds-to-the-trial-of-russell-brand/

Q&A

How did Refuge respond to the Russell Brand guilty verdicts?

Refuge called the convictions long overdue justice for survivors and an important signal that abusers will be held accountable, but stressed that not all survivors in the trial received guilty verdicts and that every survivor deserves to be believed regardless of outcome.

What reforms is Refuge demanding from the justice system?

Refuge is calling for mandatory training for criminal justice professionals, proper resourcing for police, sustainable funding for specialist services, higher conviction rates for violence against women and girls offences, and robust preventative measures.

What harmful myths does Refuge say persist among justice system professionals?

Refuge says it is deeply troubling that professionals continue to perpetuate myths such as the idea that a delay in reporting or lack of physical resistance should undermine a survivor's testimony, calling these dangerous misrepresentations of abuse dynamics.

What is the scale of domestic abuse according to the article?

Recent ONS figures show around one in ten adults, 9.6 percent, experienced domestic abuse in the last year, a figure Refuge describes as just the tip of the iceberg.